7.2 C
Brussels
Saturday, November 16, 2024
Home Blog Page 155

Why do we treat people as property of their tyrants?

0

By Hasanboy Burhanov – Founder of the political opposition movement Erkin O’zbekiston (Free Uzbekistan)

On 2 October 2018, Jamal Khashoggi, a Saudi dissident journalist, was killed by agents of the Saudi government at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, Turkey. He was aware that Mohammad bin Salman, the ruler of Saudi Arabia, wants his death. So why then did Jamal willingly walk into the Saudi consulate, stepping into a house of his mortal enemy?

The reason is: having divorced his wife, he went to the Consulate to obtain a document certifying that he was no longer married, so he could marry his Turkish fiancée. Any Western democratic country would demand the same document from him to allow him to remarry, and the only way to obtain it is to kindly ask the tyrant to oblige.

The situation Jamal Khashoggi found himself in is daily reality for millions of people who fled their countries. They may have fled years ago, built a new life for themselves in Germany or France, but they are not off the hook. One day their passports would expire – they would need new ones; if not passports, then a certificate of criminal record, or a birth certificate or some other document. And the only way to get it would be to ask the tyrants they had fled from to provide it.

Legal documents required by Western democracies become a leverage tyrants employ to control and silence their opposition abroad. Every emigrant fleeing the regime knows that if they become too vocal in their criticism they may regret it when their host country requests to provide a document of paper, for which they would need to travel back to their homeland – right into dictator’s embrace.

The case of criminal record certificates, required by many EU countries for obtaining residence permits, is especially telling. Many Russian prisoners, including paedophiles and murderers, were drafted into the Wagner mercenary group to fight in Ukraine. Those who survived get their criminal record wiped – from now on they would be able to present a clean slate, properly supported by Russia-issued papers, to any EU inquiry. At the same time, Alexey Navalny – the most famous political prisoner in Russia – will not get such a luxury: his criminal record is extensive, and it includes convictions for terrorism. If the EU judges potential immigrants by their paper records, a convicted paedophile with Ukrainian blood on their hands will look much more preferable to them than a civil activist, whose real crime was to voice their dissent.

Sometimes dictators use this power quite directly. Lukashenko, the Belorussian dictator that lost elections to Svietlana Tikhanovskaya, had ceased to issue Belorussian passports abroad. So by the current EU law, Svietlana Tikhanovskaya – once her passport expires – is expected to return to Belarus and ask Lukashenko to issue a new one for her.

We recommend to stop the practices sending citizens of countries under dictatorships back to their countries, when they need to obtain some the documents from their homeland. These documents are not trustworthy, obtaining them carries risk, and requiring them gives dictatorships undue leverage over their citizens abroad.

We recommend:

  1. In all democratic countries, amendments should be adopted to regulations that require foreigners, when interacting with government and civil organizations, to present documents with a limited validity period from their country of origin. This includes police clearance certificates, civil status certificates, newly issued birth certificates, and others. If the foreigner’s country of origin is on the list of non-democratic countries, these documents may be substituted with an affidavit signed by the applicant.
  • A regulation should be adopted for all passport-related procedures, including border crossings and travel, for citizens of nations on the list of non-democratic countries. This regulation would permit the use of an expired passport and/or a valid ID issued by the country of residence, such as a residence permit or another form of identification.

We should not urge emigrants who fled their countries escaping tyranny to go back to their oppressors to ask for necessary papers putting their lives and freedom at risk.

Earthquake kills at least 100 in Herat, Afghanistan

0
Earthquake kills at least 100 in Herat, Afghanistan

A major earthquake struck Herat, Afghanistan early Saturday killing at least 100 people and triggering a spate of rescue and assessment missions by UN agencies, partners, and the de facto authorities.

Source link

Afghanistan: Aid efforts rapidly expand as post-quake death toll rises

0
Afghanistan: Aid efforts rapidly expand as post-quake death toll rises

The death toll from the major earthquake that pummelled western Afghanistan soared over 1,000 overnight as rescue operations continued to fan out over affected villages, UN agencies said on Sunday.

Source link

Namur by bike: explore the city and its surroundings on two wheels

0

Namur by bike: explore the city and its surroundings on two wheels

Namur, located in the heart of Wallonia in Belgium, is a city full of charm and history. With its rich architectural heritage, green parks and picturesque landscapes, Namur is an ideal destination for cycling enthusiasts. Whether you are a resident of the city or a visitor passing through, exploring Namur by bike is an unforgettable experience that will allow you to discover all the hidden treasures of this magnificent region.

The city of Namur offers numerous cycle paths which will allow you to move around in complete safety and fully enjoy your bike ride. Along the Meuse, you can admire the boats sailing peacefully on the river and enjoy the breathtaking view of the citadel which overlooks the city. You can also go to the foot of the citadel by taking the cycle path which runs along the Sambre. Once at the top, you can visit this magnificent fortified castle which offers a panoramic view of the entire region.

Outside the city, the surroundings of Namur are full of picturesque landscapes and charming villages to discover by bike. For example, you can go to the Molignée valley, known for its hilly landscapes and its old railway tracks transformed into cycle paths. This region is also famous for its caves, castles and abbeys that you can discover during your bike ride.

If you are a nature lover, don’t miss the Flemish Ardennes Natural Park. Located a few kilometers from Namur, this park offers numerous opportunities for cycling through rural and wooded landscapes. You can also take a break in one of the many typical villages of the region and taste the local specialties.

Namur is also a cultural city full of museums and historical sites to visit. By traveling by bike, you can easily get from one place to another and fully enjoy your visit. Don’t miss the Félicien Rops museum, dedicated to this famous Namur artist, nor the Saint-Aubin cathedral which is one of the most beautiful religious buildings in the region.

For those who wish to extend their stay in Namur, it is possible to rent electric bikes which will allow you to cover longer distances without getting tired. This will give you the opportunity to discover more remote places such as the Eau d’Heure lakes, where you can practice water activities and enjoy the surrounding nature.

In conclusion, Namur by bike is an experience not to be missed. Whether you are a nature lover, a history buff or simply looking for new discoveries, the city and its surroundings offer many opportunities for bike rides. So, get on your bike, put on your helmet and set off to discover Namur and its hidden treasures.

Originally published at Almouwatin.com

Israeli-Palestinian conflict – UN engages parties ahead of Security Council meeting

0
- UN engages parties ahead of Security Council meeting

Top UN officials engaged key actors amid the spiraling Israeli-Palestinian conflict while UN peacekeepers detected rocket and artillery fire exchanged across the Israel-Lebanon border ahead of Sunday’s Security Council emergency meeting on the unfolding crisis.

As the 15-member Council prepared to meet at 3 pm in New York, UN agencies were reporting that hundreds of people have been killed and thousands injured following the early Saturday morning rocket fire into Israel by Palestinian militants.

The ensuing Israeli response to the Hamas attacks included airstrikes in Gaza, where the UN agency operating there, UNRWA, had reported massive damages alongside rising death tolls.

New reports emerged of alarming food scarcity and clashes across the Israel-Lebanon border.

Israel-Lebanon border: Rocket, artillery fire

Early Sunday, the UN peacekeeping operation in Lebanon, UNIFIL, “detected several rockets fired from southeast Lebanon toward Israeli-occupied territory in the general area of Kafr Chouba and artillery fire from Israel to Lebanon in response”, according to the mission.

The UN Security Council-mandated mission, operating along an area known as the “Blue Line”, was deployed in 1978 to restore peace between Israel and Lebanon.

“We are in contact with authorities on both sides of the Blue Line, at all levels, to contain the situation and avoid a more serious escalation,” UNIFIL said in a statement. “Our peacekeepers remain in their positions and on task.”

UNIFIL said peacekeepers continued to work, “some from shelters, for their safety”.

“We urge everyone to exercise restraint and make use of UNIFIL’s liaison and coordination mechanisms to de-escalate to prevent a fast deterioration of the security situation,” the mission said.

In ‘close contact’ with key actors

At the same time, the UN chief of the Middle East Peace Process, Tor Wennesland, “is in close contact” with the United States, European Union, Qatar, Egypt, and Lebanon “to discuss the ongoing war” in Israel and Gaza, according to a social media post by his office, UNSCO.

“Priority now is to avoid further loss of civilian life and deliver much needed humanitarian aid to the Strip,” the UNSCO post said, adding that the “UN remains actively engaged to advance these efforts”.

Calls to protect civilians

Top UN officials have called for an immediate cessation of violence.

UN Secretary-General António Guterres on Saturday condemned “in the strongest terms” the attack by Hamas against Israeli towns, UN Spokesperson Stéphane Dujarric said, urging “maximum restraint” and that “all diplomatic efforts” are made “to avoid a wider conflagration”.

“Civilians must be respected and protected in accordance with international humanitarian law at all times,” the UN chief said in a statement.

UN agency raises alarm over food scarcity

As the conflict intensifies, civilians, including vulnerable children and families, face mounting challenges in accessing essential food supplies, with distribution networks disrupted and production severely hampered by hostilities, according to the World Food Programme (WFP).

“WFP urges safe and unimpeded humanitarian access to affected areas, calling on all parties to uphold the principles of humanitarian law, taking every necessary measure to safeguard the lives and well-being of civilians, including ensuring access to food,” the agency said.

International Force in Haiti to fight against gangs

0
International Force in Haiti to fight against gangs

The Kenyan government has volunteered to lead an international force in Haiti and will deploy 1,000 troops to the Caribbean country

The United Nations Charter has authorized the deployment of the Multinational Security Support Mission (MSSM) to Haiti. The resolution, which was passed on Monday, October 2 2023 recognizes that the ongoing situation, in Haiti poses a risk, to peace, security and stability in the surrounding region.

The Haitian government has been asking for a mission to restore order for a year. Kenya has said it is ready to send 1,000 police officers, an offer welcomed by the United States and other countries reluctant to send their own troops to this risky terrain. Around 2,000 individuals are set to be deployed to Haiti by the end of January 2024 including 1,000 police officers from Kenya. Their primary objective will be to assist the Haitian National Police in dismantling gangs and restoring order throughout the country.

Additionally a thousand police and military personnel from Caribbean nations such as Jamaica, Bahamas, Suriname, Barbados and Antigua are expected to join forces with Kenyas contingent. Approved by the UN this international mission is significantly lower compared to previous peacekeeping efforts made in Haiti.

During the UN intervention in 1994 led by the United States there were up to 21,000 soldiers involved. The primary objective at that time was to reinstate Jean Bertrand Aristide as the elected president, after his overthrow three years prior.

In 2004 a multinational mission, under the leadership of Brazil consisted of 13,000 individuals. This mission concluded in 2017 following a series of scandals involving peacekeepers (such as incidents of rape, sexual assault and engagement with prostitutes). Accusations against a camp associated with the Nepalese contingent, for introducing cholera (which resulted in nearly 10,000 deaths) all while failing to achieve its intended goals. The primary objective was to dismantle gangs promote police and judicial system reform while maintaining peace and stability.

Fear of abuses by the international force

Many human rights groups are concerned, about violations as the Kenyan police have been accused of committing abuses, within their own nation.

NGOs, on the ground have been reporting instances of corruption, use of force arbitrary arrests and even summary executions. Amnesty International has expressed concern over the perceived methods employed by the Haitian police drawing parallels to those of the Kenyan police. They fear a violation of human rights.

This situation presents a risk since this mission while supported by the UN is not directly controlled by the body. Kenya holds authority in this regard.

Regarding this matter the United States seeks to provide reassurance. As a financier of the mission they propose implementing a monitoring mechanism to prevent any abuses. However further details on this mechanism have not been disclosed. Additionally Washington emphasizes Kenyas experience, in peacekeeping missions in Somalia and the Democratic Republic of Congo.

Fear of Gangs

The head of the G9 gang Jimmy “Barbecue” Chérizier, who used to be a police officer issued a statement stating that the international force would be received warmly only if it came “to arrest the Prime Minister and help us restore order”. Otherwise, the man considered one of Haiti’s most powerful men says he is ready to fight “to the bitter end”.

In order to effectively address the issue of armed groups, which reportedly have control, over 80% of the capital the mission will need to take action within working class neighborhoods and shantytowns. This will require cooperation with a police force that has experienced a considerably decrease, in its workforce in recent years.

Currently the number of police officers, on duty has dropped to less than 9,000 showing a decrease from the previous count of 16,000 officers in 2021. In populated areas like these any form of intervention carries risks due to criminals extensive knowledge of the terrain.

Considering these circumstances and taking into account the challenge international force in Haiti face in distinguishing between bandits and local residents it appears that the international mission is grappling with a power balance.

All the more so since the population is arming itself. As, per the United Nations there have been incidents where militias and groups claiming to be “self defense” have caused the death of over 350 individuals since April due, to the prevailing sense of insecurity. There have been extremely brutal acts of revenge, with gang members being burned alive in the street.

Read more:

Rights chief calls for international help to provide ‘way out of chaos’ in Haiti

An unprecedented invasion of jellyfish in the Black Sea

0

A horrible invasion of jellyfish is noticed in the waters of the Black Sea. The residing “compot” is off the coast of Constanta. This is what Romanian ProTV studies. Biologists reassure that they aren’t harmful, however advise folks to not contact them.

Jellyfish will be seen close to the seashores of Constanta and the resorts of Eforie, Kostinesti and Mangalia.

The lung jellyfish species can attain 60 cm in diameter. The higher half of the physique is bluish.

According to scientists, the enhance in inhabitants is because of increased temperatures. Jellyfish seem extra in autumn, when the north wind and storms carry them to the coast.

Illustrative Photo by Magda Ehlers: https://www.pexels.com/photo/glowing-pink-jellyfish-2832767/

Armenia: UN launches urgent appeal to help refugees fleeing Karabakh

0
Armenia: UN launches urgent appeal to help refugees fleeing Karabakh

The UN and its partners launched on Saturday an emergency response plan to help 136,000 refugees, appealing for $97 million to respond to urgent needs of those who fled the Karabakh region and their hosts in Armenia.

Source link

Germany: Bavaria and the return of religious cleansing in the EU

0
Germany and the return of religious cleansing in the EU

You may be surprised that a “democratic” country like Germany, with the past we know, would engage in a religious cleansing today. Who wouldn’t be? Nevertheless, as hard as it is to believe it, what some called a “cultural genocide” (Cultural genocide is the systematic destruction of traditions, values, language, and other elements that make one group of people distinct from another) is happening today in Germany, touching thousands of lives in some of the German landers.

The target of this cleansing: The Scientologists. Whatever you think or know about Scientologists, whether you think you like them or not, what we are going to expose goes beyond the boundaries of what should be tolerated from any State, moreover from a founding member of the European Union.

Sect Filters in Germany

As was reported recently by USCIRF (US Commission on International Religious Freedom) in a report called “Religious Freedom Concerns in the European Union”, for several decades now, Germany practiced what they call the “sect-filter”, which consists of the following: Anybody looking for a job, or for doing business with public institutions and companies, should sign a statement that she or he is not a Scientologist nor does she or he “uses the technology of L. Ron Hubbard” (the founder of Scientology, 1911–1986).

In fact, these sect filters go as far as asking if you or any of your employees or even volunteers have attended a lecture organized by a Scientology group, Church or linked organization during the last three years. If your answer is yes, then you will never be able to be retained for a job in a public institution, or even in a private company or association which has contracts with a public institution. And if you represent a company, you will have to terminate contracts with any person (whether it is one of your employees or an external contractor) who would answer yes to the above questions, if you want to keep doing business with public institutions.

While you would think that this would only apply to sensitive jobs or contracts, in fact, these sect filters also apply to jobs like tennis coach, gardener, marketer, engineer, architect, printer, IT expert, events manager, constructor, trainer, accounts auditor, driving school teacher, programmer, supplier of waste sacks and waste bags, web designer, interpreter etc.

Asking about the religious beliefs of a candidate before hiring them, and making it a factor of decision in the hiring process, is of course absolutely illegal. It’s illegal per the EU Employment Equality Directive which requires all Member States to protect against discrimination on grounds of religion and belief in employment, occupation, and vocational training. But it’s also illegal per the European Convention of Human Rights, as it’s a blatant discrimination based on religious grounds, and so violates Article 9 (Freedom of Religion or Belief) and Article 14 (right to non-discrimination).

In fact, there are dozens of court decisions in Germany which judged that such “sect filters” were illegal, including some by federal higher courts, and that they constitute a violation of the right to non-discrimination of the Scientologists, many of them adding that Scientology and Scientologists were to receive protection under article 4 (on Freedom of religion or belief) of the German Fundamental Law (German Constitution).

Unfortunately, the sanctions and penalties resulting from these court rulings seem to be of no effect on some landers as Bavaria, and they continue the practice of “sect filters” every day as if nothing happened.

The EU Commission Corrupted by the German Sect Filters

Tenders at the official European Union website for state agencies of Germany cleansing out Scientologists from all sorts of jobs.

What is even more concerning, is that such “sect filters” of Germany can be found by the hundreds on the EU official website for European public tenders, TED[1]. The European Commission is then unwillingly forwarding these discriminatory practices, without having yet tried to correct them.

Since the beginning of 2023, more than 300 German tenders containing “sect filters” discriminating against anyone belonging to the Church of Scientology or associating with Scientologists appeared on the EU website.

Germany, in addition to being aware of its own court decisions, could have corrected the situation in 2019 when questioned by the United Nations Special Rapporteurs on Minorities Issues (Fernand Varennes) and the one on Freedom of Religion or Belief (Ahmed Shaheed) in these terms:

“…we would like to express our concern about the continued use of measures that explicitly prevent individuals from obtaining grants and employment opportunities otherwise extended to the general population, on the basis of religion or belief. (…) Individuals identifying as Scientologists should not have to endure undue scrutiny nor disclose their beliefs…”

UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief & UN Special Rapporteur on Minority Issues Ref: AL DEU 2/2019

But it didn’t and chose to continue erring on the sides of the religious cleansers.

Can you imagine that because of your religious or philosophical beliefs, you’d be barred from applying to jobs for which you have perfect and legitimate qualifications? Even if your qualifications are those of a competent gardener, the fact that you would belong to your religious group would stick on you an infamous label preventing you from getting the job that would feed your family. Without a job, without a salary or resources, death is not far. And when death is involved and planned for a category of citizens belonging to a certain religious group, genocide is not far either.  

Dehumanization

This kind of discriminatory practices already happened in history, unfortunately in many places. And we know where it leads. Dehumanization of part of a population is a way to justify future hate crimes. The sect filters are in some way dehumanizing Scientologists. They are not anymore full citizens, but some kind of sub-citizens, who do not enjoy the same rights than others when it comes to being able to work. By using those “sect filters”, the German authorities also try to punish people who, even not being Scientologists, would associate with Scientologists in any manner, increasing then the feeling of being segregated and ostracized by thousands of German citizens, targeted and selected on the basis of their belief.

But the dehumanization of Scientologists by Bavarian authorities goes even further. On the 30th of September 2020, the Minister of Interior of the Bavarian government Joachim Herrmann, gave a press conference to present a new edition of the brochure “The Scientology System” and a short film “10 Tips on How Not to Get Fooled – This Time by Scientologists”. Inter-alia, the film featured images explaining how to throw Scientology books into the garbage (burning them may have seemed too old-fashioned) and depicting Scientologists as robots not to be trusted. They almost reached here the pinnacle of dehumanization.

A Scientologist depicted as a robot in a Bavarian Ministry of Interior's
A Scientologist depicted as a robot in a Bavarian Ministry of Interior’s video

Hate Crimes

Only a few weeks after this press conference, on December 12, 2020, an arson attack occurred against the Church of Scientology of Berlin. Sometime a bit later, stones were thrown through the windows of the Church of Scientology of Munich. This kind of hate crime doesn’t just happen. They result from a climate of hate and stigmatization. Anyone who has studied genocides knows that before a genocide could occur, a long process of undermining by hate propaganda must take place. Hatemongers come first and then hate crimes occur. When the hatemongers are a government, then hate crimes become easy, as the perpetrators may even feel they are backed by their own government. And in fact, this is the case in Germany.

Germany : Which Cult is Governing Munich, article by Georges Elia Sarfati in New Europe
Which Cult is Governing Munich, article by Georges Elia Sarfati in New Europe

As Franco-Israeli Jewish philosopher Georges Elia Sarfati wrote in New Europe in May 2019,

“Is Germany in 2019 really the democratic state we believe? Are freedom of conscience and expression respected by the authorities, as most Europeans think? There is every reason to believe that this is not the case when we consider the poor faith trials, as well as the discrimination suffered by the followers or sympathisers of the Church of Scientology whose inspiration and value system have their source in the thought and work of the writer L. Ron Hubbard. (…) Has Bavaria, once known for its strong pro-Nazi tradition, not overcome this shameful tradition of quarantining a minority? As a Franco-Israeli scholar, I wonder about the persistence of ways that defeat the idea of ​​a Europe with tolerance and equality (…) Discrimination of persons is not an abstract notion. It is a silent process that leads to exclusion, marginalisation and stigmatisation. Exclusion, in this case, targets people who are at risk of unemployment. The economic and social marginalisation that this situation often entails is a factor of desocialisation. As for the stigmatisation that results, it is to banish those who are the object of this double indignity.”

Franco-Israeli Jewish philosopher Georges Elia Sarfati

Will Religious Cleansing Continue?

There is no doubt that these shocking practices, which can be seen without forcing imagination as a system of religious cleansing, are aimed at preventing a certain category of people from earning an honest livelihood, with the ultimate purpose of erasing their particular religious group in Germany. In fact, the Bavarian authorities are not even shy about it. What’s more intriguing is the fact that the European Commission did not yet intervene to put an end to the practice of “sect filters” in its public tenders’ website. This has certainly gone unnoticed for some time. But it should not continue now. European Union faces many challenges. It’s easy to cast stones at undemocratic countries and blame them for their criminal behaviours. But the real challenge is to track down these criminal behaviours among the countries of the Union and be efficient enough to put an end to them. Without that, the Union will lose its meaning, and its fundamental rights charter will stay an empty shell.


[1] TED (Tenders Electronic Daily) is the online version of the ‘Supplement to the Official Journal’ of the EU, dedicated to European public procurement.

European Green Bond: MEPs approve new standard to fight greenwashing

0
European Green Bond: MEPs approve new standard to fight greenwashing

MEPs on Thursday adopted a new voluntary standard for the use of a “European Green Bond” label, the first of its kind in the world.

The regulation, adopted by 418 votes in favour, 79 against and 72 abstentions, lays down uniform standards for issuers who wish to use the designation ‘European green bond’ or ‘EuGB’ for the marketing of their bond.

The standards will enable investors to direct their money more confidently towards more sustainable technologies and businesses. It will also give the company issuing the bond more certainty that their bond will be suitable to investors who want to add green bonds to their portfolio. This will increase interest for this kind of financial product and support the EU’s transition to climate neutrality.

The standards align with the EU’s taxonomy framework that defines which economic activities the EU considers environmentally sustainable.

Transparency

All companies choosing to adopt the standards and therefore also the EuGB label when marketing a green bond will be required to disclose considerable information about how the bond’s proceeds will be used. They would also be obliged to show how these investments feed into the transition plans of the company as a whole. The standard therefore requires companies to be engaging in a general green transition.

The disclosure requirements, set out in so-called “template formats”, can also be used by companies issuing bonds which are not yet able to adhere to all the strict standards of the EuGB but still wish to signal their green aspirations.

External reviewers

The regulation establishes a registration system and supervisory framework for external reviewers of European green bonds – the independent entities responsible for assessing whether standards are being adhered to. It also stipulates that any actual or potential conflicts of interest external reviewers may face are properly identified, eliminated or managed, and disclosed in a transparent manner.

Flexibility

Until the taxonomy framework is fully up and running, issuers of a European Green Bond would need to ensure that at least 85% of the funds raised by the bond are allocated to economic activities that align with the EU’s Taxonomy Regulation. The other 15% can be allocated to other economic activities provided the issuer complies with the requirements to clearly explain where this investment will go.

Quote

The rapporteur, Paul Tang (S&D, NL) said, “Businesses want to make the green transition. And the European Green Bond gives them the best tool yet to help them finance this shift. It provides a transparent and trustworthy tool to drive a company’s transition plan.

Today’s vote is the starting shot for business to get serious about their green bond issuances. Investors are eager to invest in European Green Bonds and from today onwards business can start developing them. This way European Green Bonds can boost Europe‘s transition to a sustainable economy.”

Background

The green bond market has seen exponential growth since 2007 with annual green bond issuance breaking through the USD half trillion mark for the first time in 2021, a 75% increase compared to 2020. Europe is the most prolific issuance region, with 51 % of the global volume of green bonds in 2020. Green bonds represent about 3-3.5% of overall bond issuance.

Responding to the concerns of citizens

With the adoption of this legislation, Parliament is responding to the demands of citizens made in the conclusions of the Conference on the Future of Europe, notably in proposals 3(9), 11(1) and 11(8).